Impressive Moot Team

The Cayman Islands Law School moot team has recently returned from a successful trip to the Commonwealth Moot Competition in Nairobi, Kenya.

The team, consisting of Ms Elkie Rose, Ms Nadine Watler and Ms Pamella Mendez, competed against teams representing regions from across the entire Commonwealth, including the Caribbean, Australia, Canada, India, South Africa and South-East Asia. Accompanying the team was Law School lecturer, Mr. Andrew Woodcock.

A “moot” is a mock legal argument, requiring students to appear before a panel of judges and present a legal argument. In this case, the argument related to a trade dispute between two fictitious African states. Students are marked on the quality of their legal argument, their presentation in court, and their ability to answer questions.

The Cayman Islands team was ranked third, after Australia and South Africa. This achievement should be put in the context that each team competing represented an entire country following national selection competitions – the Indian team, for example, was representative of over 600 law schools.

Law School Director, Mr. Mitchell Davies, praised the team’s performance noting that “the appearance at the finals of the competition marked the culmination of many weeks of hard work and preparation. The good showing of the team has without doubt put the Cayman Islands Law School in the spotlight in the community of Commonwealth law schools.”

Attendance at the competition was made possible through the generous support of the Law School’s sponsors: the Cayman Islands Law Society, Cayman National Bank, Maples and Calder, National Development Bank, and Solomon Harris.

Plans are now under way to send another team of mooters to an international human rights moot competition at St Thomas University in Miami in January 2008.

0
0

Mooting Final

One of the highpoints in the Cayman Islands Law School’s spring calendar has come back into bloom.

The grand finale of the mooting competition for the school was recently held in the Grand Court. Normally an annual event run by the school for their students, this year’s competition was the first in the last two years, in light of Hurricane Ivan in September 2004.

The competition is premised upon a ‘moot’ point within the law that two opposing teams must argue in a Court of Appeal setting. Teams of two, which appear in the roles of appellants and respondents, are judged on courtroom manner and etiquette; organisation; structure; content; presentation; and delivery of their respective arguments.

“Mooting is an important advocacy training and public speaking experience for law students, especially those who wish to specialise in litigation in their future legal careers,” Director of Legal Studies Mitchell Davies notes.

Having eliminated two other teams in the competition’s first rounds, the two remaining teams — Mr Christopher Levers and Ms Amanda Wong (Team 1) and Mr Gary Harris and Mr Martin Davies (Team 2) — argued on a Tort law moot point concerning the duty of care. The mooting final was held 17 March.

After a long deliberation, the competition’s two judges commended both teams for their advocacy skills and exceptional court room manner. Mr Levers and Ms Wong of Team 1 were recognised for their ability as natural advocates. Mr Davies of Team 2 was singled out for the impressive structure of his argument, while teammate Mr Harris was commended for the confidence of his delivery.

In what the judges acknowledged was a difficult and close decision, Mr Levers and Ms Wong were declared winners on both points of the appeal and subsequently, winners of the overall moot.

Presiding as judges of the competition were Ms Nicola Aries, a senior lecturer from Kingston University’s Law School in London, and Dr Alan Sprince, law lecturer at the Cayman Islands Law School (CILS).

Ms Aries was visiting the Cayman Islands on a research scholarship. She is a Principal Lecturer at the Kingston University School of Law, London. She was awarded a National Teaching Fellowship by the Higher Education Academy in 2004 based on her work in teaching legal skills to undergraduate students. Ms Aries was the coach for law school’s teams that won the National Client Interviewing Competition for England & Wales in 2001 and 2004. She was also asked to bring these skills to bear in helping to prepare a CILS team comprising Mr Gary Harris and Mr Nathan Morrison that competed in an international Client Counselling competition in Cardiff, Wales, in early April 2006. Ms Aries also made a presentation to CILS staff during her visit.

Director Davies thanks Ms Deborah Barker, Professional Practice Course Leader, for her efforts in ensuring that the mooting competition was re-introduced this year to the CILS calendar. Mr Davies also thanks the Chief Justice, the Hon. Mr Justice Anthony Smellie, QC, for kindly allowing the use of Court Room One, thereby ensuring the authenticity of the occasion for the 2006 mooting finalists.

Congratulating both teams for their preparation and performance, Mr Davies expresses happiness that the mooting competition is now back on schedule. The CILS lost its home in the Tower Building following Ivan, and had to work out of temporary premises so that classes for the 2004-2005 academic year could continue, albeit after a slightly delayed start. Early in 2005, the law school moved to its new home in the former CIBC Building on Edward Street in downtown George Town, across from the Courts Building.

0
0

Law Clinic in Houston

The Cayman Islands Law School recently made its presence felt for the first time in a regional law clinic held at a well-known law school in Texas. The clinic also attracted attendance by several US law schools.

Representing the Cayman Islands Law School (CILS) at the Thurgood Marshall Law School in Houston from 22 to 24 March were Ms Chanda Glidden, a 4th year Professional Practice Course student, and 2nd year LL.B students Ms Rachel Smyth and Ms Marlene Bovell. According to Mr. Mitchell Davies, the Director of the Cayman Islands Law School, who accompanied the students to the law clinic, the Cayman team acquitted itself well.

“The unique experience of interacting on these legal problems with students from a number of different law schools was an invaluable one. The CILS students demonstrated maturity and confidence in their presentations and in dealing with questions, and in doing so raised awareness both of the CILS and the quality of its students,” Mr Davies commented.

Next spring, the beneficial experience from such an attendance is hoped to be shared with all CILS students. The venue for the next clinic scheduled for spring 2007 is expected to move to Cayman for the first time, according to a CILS media release.

All of the West Indies Council of Legal Education law schools, consisting of the Norman Manley Law School (Jamaica), the Hugh Wooding Law School (Trinidad) and the Eugene Dupuch Law School (Bahamas), were represented at this year’s clinic. Also represented were the following US law schools: Florida Coastal School of Law, Nova Southeastern University Law School, Stetson Law School, and the Thurgood Marshall Law School.

On 23 March, students in combined teams, drawn from all the law schools represented at the clinic, made presentations to the Assistant Attorneys-General from the Texas Attorney General’s office. The five separate presentations involved different problems which had been drafted by the Attorney General’s office. These were based on real problems, focused on different aspects of Texas family law, being encountered by that office.

Each problem had a Private International Law dimension, making the issues of particular relevance to the Cayman team, noted CILS Director Davies. Private International Law is a discrete subject taught in Year 3 at CILS. “It involves private law issues such as contract law or, in this case family law, having foreign elements; for example: whether a maintenance order made by the Florida court is enforceable in Texas,” Mr. Davies explained.

0
0